I absolutely support bringing back an open world that encourages exploration, discovery, and interaction, but it needs to be much more than just a large, flat landscape. I'm not going to get into the technical challenges of accomplishing this that Suneiku mentioned, although his points are certainly valid. Those are ultimately engineering problems that need to be solved, rather than reasons to compromise on the vision for what the world should be.
The world needs depth, elevation, contours, and meaningful geographical features. Mountains, valleys, lakes, rivers, streams, forests, deserts, coastlines, and recognizable landmarks. Different environments should feel genuinely different, with unique resources, creatures, NPCs, challenges, and reasons to explore. Terrain should influence how we travel, where we build, and how we interact with the world.
I like the concept of players exploring a massive world and choosing where to establish their lands and kingdoms. That could create some really interesting opportunities for strategic settlement, territorial expansion, and guild development. But the world needs to feel alive, not simply be an enormous empty landscape where everyone drops their plots.
I am very concerned about what would happen to existing guild lands and the investments already made in them.
How will guild lands be refunded or compensated? Players contributed real value to guild banks, and those funds were used to purchase land based on the game's original direction and promises. Much of that investment has provided little practical benefit.
Guilds were originally marketed as something much more substantial than what we have today. Unfortunately, despite all the time and resources invested, guild functionality is barely more developed than it was when guilds operated primarily through Discord.
Before introducing another land system, I'd really like to see a clear explanation of how existing investments will be protected and how guilds will actually fit into this new world. Will guilds be able to establish territories, build settlements, construct shared facilities, defend their lands, and create something meaningful together?
Equally important, the original promises and expectations associated with purchased lands need to be honored in good faith. Players made purchasing decisions based on what those lands were represented to offer, both in terms of functionality and future value. Any transition to a new land system should preserve those benefits and expectations, not diminish them or effectively devalue what players have already invested in. A new system should build upon those commitments rather than redefine them after the fact.
I think the proposed direction has tremendous potential, but it needs to be more than a visual overhaul or another reset of existing systems. Give us a world worth exploring, land worth owning, kingdoms worth building, and guilds that finally deliver on their original promise.